Coach Diner Menu
10 items in 5 sections · $4.50 – $9.75 · Diner in New Windsor, NY
Coach Diner’s menu lists 10 dishes and drinks, grouped into Appetizers & Finger Foods, Soups, Salads, Sandwiches, and From the Chicken Coop. Prices range from $4.50 to $9.75, and a typical item costs about $7.95. Popular choices include Shrimp in the Basket, Soup & Salad, Caribbean Chicken Salad, Tuna Melt, and New Windsor Chicken Cutlet Sandwich.
Appetizers & Finger Foods 2
- Shrimp in the Basket$7.95
With French fries
- Quesadilla with Cheese Only$6.50
Soups 2
- Soup & Salad$6.95
Cup of soup and large house salad
- Soup to Go
Served with crackers
Salads 2
- Caribbean Chicken Salad$9.45
- Spinach Salad$7.95
Sandwiches 2
- Tuna Melt$8.95
- Grilled American Cheese$4.50
From the Chicken Coop 2
- New Windsor Chicken Cutlet Sandwich$9.75
With mozzarella cheese and fried onion on a roll
- Chicken Cutlet Teriyaki$9.75
Marinated chicken cutlets, grilled and served on a roll
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.